May/June 2018 | Jerry Dubin | FANFARE Magazine - Issue 41:5 | Jascha Heifetz: The Legendary Los Angeles Concerts
« [...] Heifetz plays magnificently; I’ll give him that. In fact, on a purely technical level, though his interpretation hasn’t changed to any noticeable degree, I think he plays better in this 1954 performance than he does just a year later in his best-known recording of the work with Charles Munch and the Boston Symphony Orchestra. Munch, however, seems to have let Heifetz take the lead, so that the Boston reading sounds more of a meeting of the minds between soloist and conductor than this one does with Mehta. [...]
In both this Los Angeles recording with Mehta and the Boston recording a year later with Munch, Heifetz uses the Auer-Heifetz cadenzas, but thanks to Mehta as a mediating influence where possible, the LA performance feels marginally slower and more relaxed than the Boston performance. Indeed, the more I listen to this LA reading of the piece, the more persuaded I am that it’s Heifetz’s best and most beautiful version of the Beethoven Concerto. [...]
Here’s where I’d be expected to say that the collection at hand is mainly for diehard Heifetz fans. With the exception of the Beethoven, however, I’m not sure I can recommend this even to the most dedicated Heifetz admirers, since nothing in these performances improves upon or differs in any significant way from other recordings of these works the violinist made in generally better sounding transfers and more readily available releases. If something could be done with the Beethoven —like suppressing the annoying cough and trimming the four minutes of applause down to four or five seconds— it might well be one of my top choices for a performance of the concerto. The LA orchestra sounds really great, and Mehta brings out some interesting patterns in the inner voices that I don’t believe I’ve ever heard before. [...]
The well-documented booklet contains a number of good quality black-and-white photos, along with a well-written, informative essay on Heifetz’s life and career. »
|